Your Cart

Smash vs. Classic: Which Burger Style Reigns Supreme?

Smash vs. Classic: Which Burger Style Reigns Supreme?

May 08, 2025

Bilal Ashraf

A Burger Valley Deep Dive

Few debates ignite the passion of burger lovers quite like the battle between Smash and Classic burgers. At Burger Valley, where every patty is crafted for delivery perfection, this rivalry isn’t just about taste—it’s about experience, texture, and what makes a burger truly unforgettable. Let's embark on a delectable exploration of both styles and assist you in selecting the best option for your upcoming order.

What Makes a Smash Burger?

Smash burgers are all about technique. The beef patty starts as a loosely packed ball, then is pressed hard onto a hot griddle, creating maximum contact with the surface. This “smash” forms a deeply caramelized crust-known as the Maillard reaction-that locks in juices and delivers a signature crispy edge with every bite.

Key Smash Burger Features:

  • Thin, crispy-edged patties

  • Intense beefy flavor from the seared crust

  • Simple toppings that let the meat shine

  • Perfect bun-to-patty ratio for handheld enjoyment

At Burger Valley, our Classic Beef Burger and Tripple Cheese Burger showcase this style: double or even quadruple patties, melted cheese, and just the right amount of sauce and veggies to complement, not overpower, the star of the show.

The Classic Burger: Timeless and Layered

Classic burgers are the comfort food icons you imagine at diners and backyard barbecues. These burgers feature thicker patties, usually seasoned simply with salt and pepper, and cooked to a juicy medium. The bun is soft and sturdy-often sesame-seeded-ready to hold a stack of toppings.

Classic Burger Hallmarks:

  • Thicker, juicy patties with a tender bite

  • Traditional toppings: lettuce, tomato, onion, pickles, and cheese

  • Balanced, layered flavors in every mouthful

  • A nostalgic, hearty eating experience

Burger Valley’s Classic Beef Burger embodies this tradition, offering a double patty for extra satisfaction, melted cheese, and all the classic fixings.

Smash vs. Classic: The Ultimate Burger Showdown

Let’s break down the differences so you can pick your champion:

Feature

Smash Burger

Classic Burger

Patty Thickness

Thin, crispy edges

Thick, juicy center

Cooking Method

Smashed on a hot griddle

Gently pressed or hand-formed, grilled/fried

Flavor Profile

Intense, beef-forward, caramelized crust

Balanced, juicy, with layered toppings

Toppings

Simple: cheese, pickles, onions, sauce

Lettuce, tomato, onion, pickles, cheese, etc.

Eating Style

Quick, handheld, snackable

Hearty, filling, classic meal

Why Smash Burgers Are Winning Hearts

Smash burgers have surged in popularity for good reason. The crispy crust is addictive, the patties cook fast (perfect for delivery), and the flavor is bold and satisfying. The “bun hug” ensures every bite is balanced-no sliding toppings, no soggy bread.

At Burger Valley, our Royal Smashed Burger takes this to the max: four smashed patties, each layered with cheese and classic toppings, all held together by a soft bun that soaks up every drop of flavor.

The Classic Burger’s Enduring Appeal

Yet, the classic burger isn’t going anywhere. Its thicker patty offers a juicy, meaty bite that’s hard to beat. The layering of fresh toppings and sauces creates a symphony of textures and tastes. For many, this is the burger of childhood memories and comfort food cravings.

Burger Valley’s Take: The Best of Both Worlds

As a cloud kitchen, Burger Valley is built for delivery-no dine-in, just pure burger joy brought straight to your door. Our menu celebrates both burger traditions:

  • Smash Burgers: Fast-cooked, crispy, and packed with flavor. Try the Tripple Cheese or BBQ Cheeseburger for a modern twist.

  • Classic Burgers: Double patties, fresh toppings, and that timeless burger satisfaction. The Classic Beef Burger is a fan favorite for a reason.

Which Burger Should You Order?

  • Craving crispy edges and a beefy punch? Go Smash.

  • Want a juicy, hearty, layered bite? Classic is your pick.

  • Feeling adventurous? Try our Royal Smashed Burger or Oh Cowboy Burger for a unique spin.

Perfect Pairings from Burger Valley

No burger is complete without the right sides. Pair your burger with:

  • Skin on Fries or Cajun Fries for that essential crunch

  • BV Loaded Fries for a decadent treat

  • Onion Rings or Crispy Chicken Tenders for extra indulgence

  • And don’t forget dessert-our Chocolate Fudge Cake is the perfect sweet ending.

The Verdict: There’s No Wrong Choice

At Burger Valley, we believe every burger lover deserves their perfect bite. Smash and Classic burgers each offer something unique-crispiness versus juiciness, simplicity versus nostalgia. The real winner? You, when you order from Burger Valley and experience both styles delivered hot and fresh to your door.

Ready to settle the debate? Order your favorite burgers in Streatham style from Burger Valley today and taste the difference for yourself!